Carthage · Language and writing

Punic language and writing

Twenty-two consonants, written right to left: the alphabet brought from Phoenicia carried the language of Carthage for centuries — and it is the ancestor of ours.

Semitic languageWritten right to left22 letters
Carthage, in Punic

Qrtḥdšt

Qart-hadasht, “the New City”: Carthage’s name as its people wrote it, without vowels.

22

letters, all consonants: the Phoenician alphabet

0

vowels written in classical Phoenician script

~800

BC: the Nora Stone, 9th–8th c. (Sardinia), one of the oldest Phoenician inscriptions in the West

~400

AD: Saint Augustine still hears Punic spoken in the countryside

The 22 letters

The Phoenician alphabet

Each letter is named after a word that begins with it. The meanings of these names are traditional; some remain uncertain.

  1. 1ʾālepʾ · oxΑ · A · ا
  2. 2bētb · houseΒ · B · ب
  3. 3gīmlg · camelΓ · C, G · ج
  4. 4dāletd · doorΔ · D · د
  5. 5hēh · uncertainΕ · E · ه
  6. 6wāww · hookϜ, Υ · F, V, U, W, Y · و
  7. 7zayinz · weaponΖ · Z · ز
  8. 8ḥētḥ · fenceΗ · H · ح
  9. 9ṭētṭ · uncertainΘ · ط
  10. 10yōdy · handΙ · I, J · ي
  11. 11kapk · palmΚ · K · ك
  12. 12lāmedl · goadΛ · L · ل
  13. 13mēmm · waterΜ · M · م
  14. 14nūnn · fishΝ · N · ن
  15. 15sāmeks · supportΞ · س
  16. 16ʿayinʿ · eyeΟ · O · ع
  17. 17pēp · mouthΠ · P · ف
  18. 18ṣādēṣ · uncertainϺ · ص
  19. 19qōpq · uncertainϘ · Q · ق
  20. 20rēšr · headΡ · R · ر
  21. 21šīnš · toothΣ · S · ش
  22. 22tāwt · markΤ · T · ت

Under each letter: scholarly transliteration, traditional meaning of the name, then the Greek letter derived from it, the Latin letter descended from it (where there is one) and the corresponding Arabic letter. The old order of the Arabic alphabet — abjad, hawwaz, ḥuṭṭī… — still follows the Phoenician one.

Your turn

Write your name in Phoenician

Type a first name (in Latin or Arabic letters): each sound is replaced by the closest Phoenician letter.

Letters: ḥēt, ʾālep, nūn, nūn, yōd, bēt, ʾālep, lāmed

  • H → ḥēt
  • A → ʾālep
  • N → nūn
  • N → nūn
  • I → yōd
  • B → bēt
  • A → ʾālep
  • L → lāmed

A playful approximation: the Phoenician alphabet had no vowels and some sounds did not exist (v, j…). The real Hannibal was written (Ḥnbʿl, “grace of Baal”), right to left.

A Semitic language

From Phoenician to Punic, then Neo-Punic

9th – 8th c. BCThe Nora Stone, in Sardinia, shows Phoenician writing already established in the western Mediterranean.
8th – 2nd c. BCPunic, the Phoenician of the West, becomes the common language of the Carthaginian world, with its own pronunciation shaped by Libyan (Lancel).
3rd – 1st c. BCThe Numidian kingdoms adopt it as a language of power: their coins carry Punic legends (Lancel).
After 146The fall of Carthage did not kill the language. “Neo-Punic” script, more cursive, now marks some vowels; inscriptions were still carved in the 1st and 2nd c. AD.
4th c. ADPunic is written in Latin letters (Lancel): the alphabet changes, the language remains.
Saint Augustine, c. 400

“Ask our peasants what they are: they answer in Punic, ‘Chanani’.”

Augustine, Epistolae ad Romanos inchoata expositio, 13

The passage is often quoted as proof that Punic was still spoken and that its speakers called themselves “Canaanites”. But the text is rhetorical and the manuscripts differ; Gabriel Camps sees it rather as a Libyan dialect, since punicus often simply meant “African” at the time.

Hypothesis

For Stéphane Gsell, and later M’hamed Hassine Fantar, the survival of a Semitic language in North Africa may have eased the Arabisation of the Maghreb centuries later.

Epigraphy

What the stones say

With no books surviving, inscriptions are our main written source. They are numerous, but often short and repetitive.

Punic stele with the sign of Tanit
Stele with the sign of Tanit, Louvre Museum
Thousands of stelae

The tophet stelae

The tophets of Carthage and other cities have yielded thousands of them, gathered in the Corpus Inscriptionum Semiticarum. Their texts are highly formulaic: they tell little about the city’s history and give a limited number of personal names.

lrbt ltnt pn bʿl wlʾdn lbʿl ḥmn

“To the Lady Tanit, face of Baal, and to the Lord Baal Hammon”: the dedication formula that opens many of Carthage’s stelae.

On these gods and the debate over the tophet, see the religion page.

Marseille, 1845

The Marseille Tariff

Found in the port of Marseille, this regulation sets, animal by animal, the share owed to the priests for each sacrifice. Specialists attribute it to Carthage.

Vieille Charité Museum, Marseille
c. 500 BC

The Pyrgi Tablets

Three gold sheets found in 1964 at the port of Caere: two in Etruscan, one in Phoenician. King Thefarie Velianas dedicates a holy place to Uni-Astarte.

Villa Giulia, Rome
2nd c. BC

The Dougga bilingual

On the Libyco-Punic mausoleum at Dougga, the same text in Punic and Libyan — a key to deciphering Libyan script. The block was torn out in 1842 by the British consul Thomas Reade.

British Museum, London
Coins

Letters in metal

Coin legends, Punic then Numidian, are inscriptions too: they show how letter shapes varied from place to place and over time.

Carthage, Bardo, British Museum
A lost literature

Libraries without books

Carthage had libraries, where Greek literature also circulated. People wrote on law, history and geography; Carthaginian philosophers are known from Diogenes Laertius and Iamblichus.

In 146, according to Pliny the Elder, the Roman Senate gave these libraries to the Numidian kings and had only Mago translated. Sallust says he consulted “Punic books” attributed to King Hiempsal; after that, their trail goes cold.

Pliny, Natural History, XVIII, 22 · Sallust, Jugurthine War, 17
What survived

Fragments, through others

MagoA treatise on agronomy in 28 books, the only Punic work translated into Latin by order of the Senate; known through Varro, Columella and Pliny. Mago the Agronomist →
HannoThe account of his voyage survives in Greek, as a translation of a Punic text displayed in a temple; its interpretation is still debated. Hanno the Navigator →
ClitomachusBorn in Carthage as Hasdrubal, he headed Plato’s Academy in Athens in the 2nd c. BC — but he wrote in Greek.
AnnalsHistory, law, geography: these writings survive only through rare allusions in Greek and Latin authors.
Legacy

The alphabet that conquered the world

The Greeks borrowed the alphabet from the Phoenicians and added vowels. Through them, then the Etruscans and the Romans, it became ours.

Lineages

Two great branches

  1. WestwardsPhoenicianGreekEtruscanLatinEuropean alphabets
  2. EastwardsPhoenicianAramaicNabataeanArabic
  3. AlsoAramaicSquare Hebrew
One letter, three alphabets

From ʾālep to A

Correspondences between Phoenician, Greek and Latin letters
PhoenicianGreekLatin
ʾālepΑA
bētΒB
dāletΔD
mēmΜM
ʿayinΟO
rēšΡR

The Greeks recycled as vowels some consonants that did not exist in their language: ʾālep became alpha (A), ʿayin became omicron (O).